Bona Law Partner Aaron Gott Presents CLE on Antitrust Law After the NAR Settlement
November 13, 2026
Bona Law partner Aaron Gott presented the antitrust segment of a continuing legal education program for real estate lawyers on November 10, 2026. The program, Commissions Moved into the Contract: Drafting and Advising After the NAR Reset, was offered live through myLawCLE and is now available on demand for attorneys who represent buyers, sellers, or lenders in residential closings, and for litigators and risk managers who advise brokerages and closing firms.
Gott's segment, The NAR Settlement and Beyond: The Current Antitrust Landscape in Real Estate, explained why a rule adopted by an association of competitors produced a jury verdict of nearly $1.8 billion (before trebling), the resulting settlement’s effects on residential transactions, and why the antitrust questions did not end with the settlement. Attendees left with a working framework for identifying antitrust red flags for their brokerage clients.
The commission litigation. The cooperative compensation rule required a listing broker to offer compensation to the buyer's broker in order to list a home on the MLS, and in 2023 a jury found a conspiracy to inflate commissions. The court tried the case as per se price fixing, so the defendants could not defend the rule by pointing to its benefits. The settlement's practice changes took effect in 2024: offers of compensation no longer appear on the MLS, and a buyer agent needs a written agreement, with the compensation stated and a disclosure that fees are negotiable, before touring a home. The United States Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit affirmed approval of the settlement in 2026. That ruling addressed the class settlement and not the merits, so no appellate court has decided whether the rule was unlawful. Homebuyers' parallel claims proceed through state indirect-purchaser statutes, because federal law bars indirect purchasers from recovering damages.
Private listing networks. In Zillow v. MRED, a federal court in Chicago denied Zillow's request for a preliminary injunction against MRED, the Chicago-area MLS, and Compass, finding that Zillow had not made a strong showing of an agreement or defined a market. Market definition is key in rule of reason cases because the plaintiff has to show market power and measure the anticompetitive effects. In Compass v. Zillow, a federal court in New York denied Compass' request to block Zillow's policy against displaying listings marketed privately, because Compass had not shown that Zillow had enough market power to exclude competitors or any collusion with Redfin. The background is NAR's Clear Cooperation Policy, adopted in 2019, which requires a broker to submit a listing to the MLS within one business day of marketing it publicly. Private-network operators, including ThePLS.com, challenged the policy as a device to eliminate competing networks, and NAR loosened it in 2025.
Regulatory posture. There is no regulatory safe harbor for private listing networks. DOJ has scrutinized the Clear Cooperation Policy for years but has said it has not taken the position that such policies standing alone are anticompetitive, and DOJ and the FTC withdrew their competitor-collaboration guidelines in 2024 and opened a public inquiry about replacing them in 2026.
Key Takeaways
- Association and MLS rules are agreements among competitors. The commission case began with a written rule, and a rule that singles out a rival network for exclusion raises group boycott concerns.
- Commission language matters. Terms such as "standard" or "customary," and pre-filled rates in association or franchisor forms, read like evidence of collective rate-setting. A blank field for the broker's own rate, with the disclosure that commissions are negotiable, is the safer approach.
- Rate talk among competitors is a red flag. Two brokers negotiating one transaction is ordinary business. Competing brokers discussing what they charge generally, whether at association meetings, franchise events, or in group chats, is not. Anyone in that conversation should leave, preserve the record, and consult antitrust counsel.
- Document independent business reasons in advance. A decision to join a private network, drop a portal feed, or discipline a member should have a contemporaneous rationale, reviewed by antitrust counsel before the decision is final.
About the Program
The program is now available on demand through the myLawCLE course page. Gott's analysis builds on Bona Law's earlier coverage of the NAR litigation, including its 2023 analysis of the $1.8 billion verdict.
Bona Law's business is to anticipate and solve antitrust and other competition problems. It represents companies in high-stakes matters nationwide (and beyond), including in real estate and housing antitrust.